Medicare for All, Not Medicare Benefit


Yves right here. This publish supplies an essential, detailed takedown of the travesty often known as Medicare Benefit. In case you are within the US and watch what I name outdated individuals TV (syndicated classics and crime exhibits), you’ll be bombarded by Medicare Benefit come-ons at the moment of 12 months. The truth that Medicare Benefit is worthwhile sufficient to help near blanket-level commercials ought to inform you that not sufficient of the premium {dollars} are going for well being care.

Medicare Benefit is serving as a second-tier scheme for budget-stressed Social Safety recipients, since many plans are nominally “no payment,” as in there isn’t any deduction from Social Safety funds, in contrast to for Medicare B (physician protection) and D (prescription protection). However since there isn’t any such factor as a free lunch, the shortage of premiums is recouped through skimpier protection.

However even worse, the medical insurance trade hopes to extend the market share of Medicare Benefit and ultimately displace conventional Medicare, and it has far too many supporters in Congress and the Administration.

Please flow into this publish extensively, significantly to these of Medicare age. And particularly, exhort recipients to contact their Congresscritters and help laws (“The Medicare for All Act of 2023” Home Invoice, (H.R. 3421, and Senate Invoice S. 1655, which might finish Medicare Benefit, in addition to the stealth non-public insurer takeover of conventional Medicare through Direct Contracting Entities and REACH plans, described intimately beneath.

Additionally word the shout out to Michael Hudson!

By F. Douglas Stephenson, LCSW, is a retired psychotherapist and former teacher of social work within the College of Florida Division of Psychiatry. He’s a member of Physicians for a Nationwide Well being Program. Cross posted from Frequent Desires

Wendell Potter, a New York Instances bestselling writer, extremely revered healthcare and marketing campaign finance reform advocate, and authority tackling company and particular curiosity propaganda, alerts us to the hazards of Medicare Benefit plans now supplied by the non-public medical insurance trade.

“In only a few weeks,” says Potter, “we’re as soon as once more going to be bombarded with adverts that includes wholesome and happy-looking seniors enjoying tennis and telling us how fantastic their Medicare Benefit plan is and the way a lot of a no brainer it’s to shun conventional Medicare and choose as a substitute for a plan operated by an enormous company like Humana and Cigna. We’ll hear insurers’ shills inform us concerning the further advantages we’ll get, like reductions on fitness center memberships; $900 for groceries; and a few protection for dental, imaginative and prescient, and listening to. They’re brief on particulars in fact, and we by no means hear that protection for these further issues may be fairly meager.”

Potter provides, “We additionally by no means hear concerning the probably lethal uncomfortable side effects of Medicare Benefit plans. Make it possible for insurers’ pitchmen—like ‘Broadway Joe’ Namath—are extra forthcoming about what we’ll be getting ourselves into if we do as he suggests. Why ought to he be allowed to go away out essential (Medicare Benefit) particulars we higher learn about earlier than we signal on the dotted line?”

How Medicare Benefit Plans Differ From Typical Medicare

  • They’re owned and operated by for-profit, non-public insurance coverage companies;
  • In contrast to conventional Medicare, Medicare Benefit plans usually refuse to pay for remedies and drugs physicians prescribe;
  • In contrast to conventional Medicare, many physicians, different healthcare professionals, and hospitals will likely be off-limits to sufferers as a result of Medicare Benefit corporations create their very own proprietary and sometimes skimpy “networks” of healthcare suppliers;
  • If sufferers exit of community, they may very well be on the hook for hundreds of {dollars} out of their very own pocket; and
  • They probably must pay further—usually quite a bit further—for a few of these further advantages.

Non-public Well being Insurance coverage Trade Dominates

The for- revenue, non-public insurance coverage trade totally dominates our nationwide medical insurance system and defines the essential idea and objective of medical insurance . The U.S. non-public enterprise mannequin of medical insurance defines insurers as business entities, and maximize income by primarily limiting advantages, maximizing well being coverage premiums, or by not protecting individuals with well being issues. Like all companies, their aim is to generate income. Underneath the enterprise mannequin, the greed of informal inhumanity is inbuilt and the frequent good of the residents and nation is ignored; excluding the poor, the aged, the disabled, and the mentally unwell is sound enterprise coverage because it maximizes revenue.

Political Help for Non-public Well being Insurance coverage Trade

As a result of our authorities permits non-public medical insurance corporations to precise giant revenue from its residents, Wall Avenue banks and traders who again Large Insurance coverage flip public cash right into a bonanza of personal riches. Excessive medical insurance prices are the results of a political determination to basically enable Large Insurance coverage to do what they need and cost no matter they need. It’s no surprise so many beholden members of Congress need to defend the pursuits of their donors, Large Insurance coverage and Large Pharma, industries that spent $371 million on lobbying in 2017.

The web site/weblog The Lever reported that The Higher Medicare Alliance, an advocacy group for Medicare Benefit plans,

spent $570,000 lobbying Congress within the first quarter of this 12 months, almost double the $330,000 spent within the prior quarter. All instructed, the 4 main publicly traded medical insurance corporations that function Medicare Benefit plans, in addition to the insurance coverage foyer America’s Well being Insurance coverage Plans, spent almost $19 million on federal lobbying within the first quarter of 2023, a 66% improve from the prior quarter, in response to a Lever evaluation of knowledge from OpenSecrets.

U.S. political and oligarch help for privatization of medical insurance is grounded within the philosophy espoused by College of Chicago economist the late Milton Friedman. Friedman stated, “The firms shouldn’t take into consideration the general public curiosity,” and added that “the federal government itself shouldn’t take into consideration the general public curiosity. The job of the federal government is to easily let all people make as a lot cash as they will, nevertheless they will.”

In distinction, classical economist Michael Hudson notes that Large Insurance coverage doesn’t need any sort of anti-monopoly laws:

Basically you may have what is known as a free market, as advocated by Milton Friedman. A free market means the wealthiest individuals dominate the market and the availability of credit score, the administration of the financial system that allocates credit score, and who will get what shifts from Washington to Wall Avenue. It shifts from the federal government to the non-public monetary sector, and permits the monetary sector to do the planning. One drawback with that is the monetary sector lives within the brief run. So, it implies that they solely search for the following three months, the following 12 months’s steadiness sheet, as a result of the free market is so advanced you don’t know what’s going to occur. Nicely, in fact, because you’re managing it from Wall Avenue you in actuality do know what’s going to occur, however you don’t need to inform individuals precisely what’s going to occur.

Large Insurance coverage Profiteering Statistics

Wendall Potter stories on latest profiteering by Medicare Benefit plans:

  1. Large Insurance coverage revenues and income have elevated by 300% and 287% respectively since 2012 attributable to explosive progress within the insurance coverage corporations’ pharmacy profit administration (PBM) companies and the Medicare substitute plans referred to as Medicare Benefit.
  2. The for-profits now management greater than 70% of the Medicare Benefit market. In 2022, Large Insurance coverage revenues reached $1.25 trillion and income soared to $69.3 billion. That’s a 300% improve in income and a 287% improve in income from 2012, when income was $412.9 billion and income have been $24 billion.
  3. Large insurers’ revenues have grown dramatically over the previous decade, the results of consolidation within the PBM enterprise and taxpayer-supported Medicare and Medicaid packages.
  4. What has modified dramatically over the last decade is that the large insurers at the moment are getting way more of their revenues from the pharmaceutical provide chain, Medicare, Medicaid, and from taxpayers as they’ve moved aggressively into authorities packages. That is very true of Humana, Centene, and Molina, which now get, respectively, 85%, 88%, and 94% of their health-plan revenues from authorities packages.
  5. The 2 greatest drivers are their fast-growing pharmacy profit managers (PBMs), the comparatively new and little-known intermediary between sufferers and pharmaceutical drug producers, and the privately owned and operated Medicare substitute plans marketed as Medicare Benefit.
  6. Large strides in privatizing each Medicare and Medicaid have been made. Greater than 90% of health-plan revenues at three of the well being trade corporations come from authorities packages as they proceed to denationalise each Medicare and Medicaid, via Medicare Benefit particularly. Enrollment in government-funded packages elevated by 261% in 10 years.

Voters Don’t Matter

The voters don’t matter as a result of the American definition of democracy is oligarchy, the place a small group workouts management particularly for egocentric functions. Polls have proven giant fashionable help by residents for Medicare for All, however neither political occasion nor Wall Avenue donors have supported it. Michael Hudson writes that by “conquering the brains of a rustic by shaping how individuals suppose, you may twist their view into ‘unreality economics’ and make them suppose you might be there to assist them and to not take cash out of them, then you definitely’ve bought them hooked.” That is how Large Insurance coverage and Large Pharma preserve management of U.S. medical insurance. Our system is privatized, financialized, and unregulated so that non-public, massive insurance coverage corporations can generate income.

The idea that regardless of the market produces is rational and practical is the bedrock of Western economies. “And it’s unsuitable,” says Hudson, “as a result of It negates the truth that you actually need some authorities energy robust sufficient to override the self-serving particular pursuits of oligarchs and different 1% company pursuits. And that takes a really robust authorities, which is why the free market /privatization individuals have at all times opposed robust authorities and why their financial fashions don’t give any acknowledgement for presidency funding in infrastructure that Biden desires or any authorities exercise that is ready to override that of the 1% rentier class, the monetary class, the property-owning class, and the company monopolists. That’s the issue now we have.”

Conventional Medicare Threatened by New Non-public Profiteers

Non-public revenue “Medicare Benefit” and “REACH” plans current new threats to Conventional Medicare.

1. What Is Medicare Benefit?

Medicare Benefit is a program providing non-public medical insurance plans as choices to exchange conventional Medicare. Medicare Benefit plans differ from conventional Medicare in that they’re paid with capitation (per member), they’re required to restrict enrollees’ out-of-pocket spending, and might provide further advantages (e.g. fitness center memberships, $900 value of groceries, dental advantages). They virtually at all times provide prescription drug protection and use an outlined and sometimes restricted community of suppliers that may require enrollees to pay extra for out-of-network care. Utilization administration strategies are used, reminiscent of prior authorization, and so they also can fund particular packages reminiscent of rewards for beneficiaries to encourage wholesome behaviors. The hope is that these variations will result in improved care at decrease price in comparison with Conventional Medicare.

In actuality, “Medicare Drawback” is a greater, extra correct title for the packages nevertheless, as insurance coverage corporations push Congress to corporatize all of Medicare, but hold the title for the needs of selling, deception, and confusion.

Dismantling Medicare With Medicare Benefit: Over 50% of Medicare beneficiaries now have for-profit companies accountable for their care via Medicare Benefit (MA). Insurance coverage corporations are paid handsomely for these plans, and far of that cash goes to company income as a substitute of care. The businesses working MA plans need to take over Medicare completely, leaving sufferers with no choice however to provide their cash to non-public insurers.

Denying Therapy: Investigations into declare denials in MA discovered that insurers have been inappropriately denying remedies and exams that must be coated below Medicare. Doctor surveys present that these practices usually trigger sufferers to endure unnecessarily, and might even be life-threatening. In some instances, MA insurers have been discovered to spend simply seconds on every declare, and even denied claims utilizing synthetic intelligence as a substitute of medical consultants.

Deceiving Sufferers and Taxpayers: Reviews from journalists, researchers, and authorities businesses have proven that medical insurance corporations like UnitedHealth and Cigna overcharge Medicare by giving sufferers exaggerated or completely false diagnoses. A number of corporations have been fined, or sued, and agreed to giant settlements. MA insurers are taking residents’ tax {dollars} for circumstances they aren’t even treating.

Backside Line: Medicare Benefit shouldn’t be the identical Medicare program that People have come to know and love. The non-public insurance coverage trade has spend hundreds of thousands on promoting with the intention to cover the ugly reality: Their MA plans raid taxpayer funds and routinely fail to ship the care that sufferers anticipate and deserve.

Terminate Medicare Benefit: Physicians for a Nationwide Well being Program, concludes that the Middle for Medicare Providers (CMS) ought to terminate the Medicare Benefit program. It might be far less expensive for CMS to enhance conventional Medicare by capping out-of-pocket prices and including improved advantages inside the Medicare fee-for-service system than to attempt to not directly provide these enhancements via non-public plans that require a lot increased overhead and introduce profiteers and perverse incentives into Medicare, enabling company fraud and abuse, elevating price to the Medicare Belief Fund, and worsening disparities in care. These issues are usually not correctable inside the aggressive non-public insurance coverage enterprise mannequin, and the Medicare Benefit program must be terminated.

2. What Is a ‘Direct Contracting Entity’ and ‘REACH’?

This program arms conventional Medicare to Wall Avenue by inserting a profit-seeking middlemen in Conventional Medicare to “handle” take care of seniors and folks with disabilities, permitting corporations to maintain as much as 40% of what they don’t spend on care as overhead and revenue. Beneficiaries are assigned. with out their information or consent. robotically to a ‘Direct Contracting Entity’ (DCE) if their main care doctor has joined one. The one approach for beneficiaries to choose out is to discover a completely different main care doctor.

Income Over Affected person Care: Income are put forward of affected person care by nearly any sort of firm to be a Direct Contracting/REACH intermediary, together with business insurance coverage corporations, non-public fairness funding companies, and different Wall Avenue profiteers. DCE’s develop profiteering to all of Medicare. Direct Contracting corporations have already enrolled 1.8 million beneficiaries, with plans to take over all of Conventional Medicare within the subsequent decade.

Terminate DCE’S and REACH: It might be far less expensive for CMS to enhance conventional Medicare by capping out-of-pocket prices and including improved advantages inside the Medicare fee-for-service system than to attempt to not directly provide these enhancements via non-public plans that require a lot increased overhead and introduce profiteers and perverse incentives into Medicare, enabling company fraud and abuse, elevating price to the Medicare Belief Fund, and worsening disparities in care. These issues are usually not correctable inside the aggressive insurance coverage enterprise mannequin, and the DCE/REACH program must be terminated.

Free Ourselves From Profiteers

We now have a number of many years of expertise with the conversion of well being and psychological healthcare right into a enterprise. Our healthcare is being rationed, with care tips decided by profitability and secrecy determined in non-public Wall Avenue company boardrooms. To comprehend giant income demanded by Wall Avenue traders, our well being system should appeal to the wholesome and switch away the sick, disabled, the poor, lots of the outdated, and the mentally unwell.

To keep up company management of U.S. healthcare insurance coverage, our system is privatized and unregulated. Non-public, massive insurance coverage corporations are within the enterprise of earning money, not offering full healthcare, and once they undertake the latter, it’s probably to not be in the very best pursuits of sufferers or to be environment friendly. Administrative prices (and immense profiteering) are better within the non-public healthcare insurance coverage system, and even Medicare itself is weakened by having to work via the non-public system.

The USA is a rustic the place medical insurance for medical and psychological healthcare is a operate of socioeconomic standing. Everybody is aware of that this inhumane system ought to have been corrected way back. We should instantly finish our ethical crime of getting the best well being system on this planet, however solely for individuals who can afford it. We should help the frequent ideas that healthcare is a human proper, should be free from company revenue, and should be achieved via nationwide laws.

Let’s always remember that common Medicare for All is a strong funding in all residents of our nation by merely selling a social service for common entry to inexpensive healthcare insurance coverage for all. Aren’t we a society that cares sufficient to see that everybody obtain the healthcare they want? That’s the essential objective of Medicare for All. The historical past of our most profitable nationwide medical insurance program, Medicare, supplies among the finest arguments for increasing this system to cowl everybody. It’s time to finish insufficient and harmful medical insurance packages. Insist on actual medical insurance reform important for people and households.

Contact your legislators asking them to oppose and finish Medicare Benefit, DCE’s, and REACH plans . Most significantly, ask them to strongly help new laws now filed in Congress, “The Medicare for All Act of 2023” Home Invoice (H.R. 3421) and Senate Invoice (S. 1655) that will set up this badly wanted reform.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email


Leave a Comment